I'd have kept more of the track as bare as the opening. The unsteady sound that comes in is interesting, but I was already getting that uncertainty from the space between the voice and piano. Giving it an extra sound draws attention to something the performance had made me hear on its own.
cellophane
SongsThe first time she asks the question, it feels exposed in a way I want to keep. Later the line is familiar enough that I start hearing the changing texture around it more than the words. I'd have traded one repetition for a longer pause with nothing but the piano.
•••
The piano leaves enough space to hear her take a breath before taking a chance on a note. That matters more to me than whether she hits it cleanly. I can hear how much she wants to finish the question and how much it costs to say it again.
•••
I love that the ending can get quieter after the question has been asked so directly. She isn't getting a clearer answer by singing bigger. Letting the track recede gives me time to hear how unresolved the question was all along.