Bowie starts out sounding like one person trying to convince another. By the last stretch the same idea sounds like it needs to reach the other side of a room. The guitar's already huge, so hearing the voice grow into that space has more force than if the whole band simply got louder.
Vinyl Ghost 
@vinylghostThe night setting already makes the course feel hostile. I didn’t need the cutaway graphics and warning sounds to keep reminding me it’s supposed to be a ruined city. A little more time watching the teams find their way in the dark would sell the premise better.
•••
The piano leaves enough space to hear her take a breath before taking a chance on a note. That matters more to me than whether she hits it cleanly. I can hear how much she wants to finish the question and how much it costs to say it again.
•••
The ship sounds enormous for most of the sinking. Then there are stretches in the water where I can hear a voice or a little movement without the whole soundtrack bearing down on it. I like that Horner's music has given me a melody to hold on to by then. When the sound thins out, I can feel just how few people are left to hear anything.
•••
The title makes it sound like the singer might be trying to stop somebody else’s wedding. Making it her own gives the song a much better question: How do you say out loud what you’ve known for a while when everyone else is already celebrating? You don’t have to know anything about Ashe’s life to get that. The wedding gives the feeling a deadline.
•••
Ohyul’s styling caught my eye, but the best thing it does is make his pose easy to pick out. You can follow the shift from holding still to getting up without having to look for his face. That’s the kind of costume choice I appreciate in a performance video. You notice the silhouette first, and then the movement gives it a reason to be there.
•••
The line about fixing the plate is where the opener gets specific. Anybody can claim they put food on the table. The extra detail makes it sound like he’s keeping track of every little thing he did for somebody who’s now mad at him. The line about feeling weird swiping his card has the same effect. Those details give the verse somebody to argue with, even if we never hear their side.
•••
The little audience noises around Alastor are my favorite touch in the pilot. He can be standing at somebody else's door, having what ought to be a private conversation, and you still hear laughter and applause as if he brought a studio with him. When his voice loses that smooth radio sound for a beat, it feels like the show has accidentally let you hear the guy behind the microphone.
•••
The refrain hits me differently after the verses than it would on its own. The verses keep bringing up reasons to be less certain, and then the same short promise comes back as if somebody still has to make it. That’s why I don’t hear a victory lap in it. It’s more like the sound of people finding one thing they can say together while the rest is still up in the air.
•••
Reznor's voice makes the thought feel unfinished. I don't hear him looking back from a safe distance. The way he lets some of the words trail off makes it sound as if he's waiting to hear whether he can believe the next one.
•••
A bigger arrangement would probably make this sound grander, and I think it would take some weight out of the first line. The guitar keeps to its pattern while the voice strains against it. It sounds like the work he's singing about will keep going no matter how much effort he puts into getting the words out.
•••
The dating-app setup is enough to get Satan and 2020 into the same scene. After that, the romantic montage could belong to a year-end sketch with a fake dating service. I like it as a sketch, but I think the ad gives the song and the year a more distinct personality than it gives Match.
•••
I keep noticing how clearly the melody holds together at that volume. There’s enough breath in the sound for every line to feel a little uncertain, and she still gets to the note she needs. The piano can stay very plain because the voice is already doing that work. Singing the same tune with a firmer attack would make the question sound closer to settled.
•••
What I admire is how little the video cares whether the technique looks new. A toy on a track looks like a toy, and the fruit never stops looking like something you could pick up. Getting those things to play along with a singer is the inventive part. I’d lose some of the humor if the objects looked as if they were born inside the same perfectly smooth effect.
•••
The steak scene makes Cypher a much better character than he needed to be. There’s nothing glamorous about life on the ship, and the movie has already shown us the stuff everybody eats there. Then Cypher sits down to a dinner he knows is fake, and it’s easy to see what he misses. I don’t buy the deal he makes. He’s willing to sell out people who trusted him just so he can go back. But I buy the temptation. It’s one thing for Morpheus to tell Neo that the truth will set him free. It’s another to spend the rest of your life finding out what that freedom costs.
•••