What bothered me was how much time the film spends explaining why Scrooge turned out this way. An explanation can make a character richer. Here I wanted to see more of the people living with the consequences of his decisions before the story asked me to be moved by his change.
Ebenezer
MoviesOn a Christmas Eve in Dickens’ London, spirits force Ebenezer Scrooge to revisit his past, confront the present, and reckon with what his future might hold.
- Director
- Ti West
- Cast
- Johnny Depp, Arthur Conti, Daisy Ridley, Ian McKellen, Rupert Grint
Ti West is an interesting pick for this story because Scrooge ought to dread what he’ll see next. The Gothic look does some of that work early on. I wish the encounters kept raising the stakes once the ghosts started telling him things he could already have guessed.
•••
There’s real promise in treating A Christmas Carol as a ghost story. The visitations put somebody who’s used to controlling his surroundings at the mercy of whoever opens the next door. I was more engaged by that idea than by the question of how sympathetic Scrooge should be.