What is Reywing?

Ethan Pladiw Profile country: United States

@ethanpladiwApproved Reywing member

17 quality commentsSongsMoviesCommercials
0 Following · 0 Followers

Obsession

Open comment

Nikki becoming devoted to Bear is frightening because Navarrette keeps affection and distress so close together. A look that ought to reassure him can suddenly seem like someone trying to get out. That makes the wish disturbing before the film needs its bigger shocks. Bear has asked for the answer he wants, and the performance keeps reminding us that an answer without a choice behind it isn’t intimacy.

1 reply
•••

Remain | Trailer

Open comment

The daylight scenes are what sell this trailer for me. Wren can look like someone he might actually build a life with, and then the darker images make that possibility feel unstable. Gyllenhaal looks drawn to her before he looks frightened. That gives the romance somewhere to go beyond being the calm stretch before the scares. I hope the movie keeps that uncertainty instead of turning the relationship into a setup for a reveal.

1 reply
•••

Ebenezer

Open comment

There’s real promise in treating A Christmas Carol as a ghost story. The visitations put somebody who’s used to controlling his surroundings at the mercy of whoever opens the next door. I was more engaged by that idea than by the question of how sympathetic Scrooge should be.

Reply
•••

cellophane

Open comment

The first time she asks the question, it feels exposed in a way I want to keep. Later the line is familiar enough that I start hearing the changing texture around it more than the words. I'd have traded one repetition for a longer pause with nothing but the piano.

2 replies
•••

Be Her

Open comment

The details make this stick. She measures herself against ordinary habits, down to how somebody pours a drink. That tells me more than a chorus about wanting to be perfect ever could. It also leaves me wondering how much of the woman is real and how much the narrator needs her to be real.

1 reply
•••

Mr. Do Something

Open comment

I hear why people put this next to “Dead Fresh.” Both tracks get a lot out of the way Baby sounds when he’s pressing a point. Here, I hear that most clearly in the switch between the longer runs and the clipped title phrase. I could use a little more of that contrast later on. Once the refrain has done its job, I’m listening for what he’ll do with the next line.

Reply
•••

I Know The End

Open comment

Once the track starts adding people and instruments, it takes a fairly straight path to the loud ending. I like the destination and wanted one quieter turn along the way. The first half has room to surprise me with a single line. The build spends most of its time making one thing more certain.

Reply
•••

Apocalypse Now

Open comment

The river journey is more convincing to me while the crew still has to manage the next checkpoint or talk to the next soldier. By the time Kurtz is speaking from the dark, the movie is asking a single voice to carry a madness the river has already shown us.

1 reply
•••

Bohemian Rhapsody

Open comment

I’d take the piano ballad and the ending on their own. There’s a particular kind of dread in how Mercury sings against that piano. The rock entrance feels like a release on a completely different scale, and once it’s over I have to find my way back to the quiet again. I enjoy the nerve of putting it all on the same record. The voice at its most exposed is the part I’d actually choose to hear twice.

1 reply
•••

Beyoncé - BREAK MY SOUL

Open comment

On its own I find the beat almost too settled. The hook arrives with a lot of confidence, but I get more from it after Energy has already got me moving. The album makes that entrance feel like a release of pressure from the previous track. Here I spend the first stretch waiting for a sense of motion I already have when I hear the two together.

2 replies
•••

Do your lesson, no buts.

Open comment

I think the clever part of this is the notification, which makes the TV spot feel incomplete to me. A reminder that appears on your phone can send you straight to a lesson. On TV the same command just ends when the owl is done. If you already use the app, that may be enough. If you don't, the spot gives you more of a mascot joke than a reason to start.

Reply
•••

Dumb Ways to Die

Open comment

I wanted the song to change shape a little sooner. The first couple of choruses make the verse jokes easy to follow, but after that the same lift comes around so often that I start listening for the hook and tuning out the setup. One verse without a full return to the chorus could give the next punch line a little room.

Reply
•••

Elden Ring

Open comment

Spirit Ashes change more than how fast the health bar goes down. When an enemy turns to face something else, I get to choose whether to heal or get around behind it. I get why some people like the rhythm of fighting alone. Sharing the enemy's attention for a bit has a rhythm of its own.

Reply
•••

Peter Gabriel - Sledgehammer

Open comment

I could lose a few of the transformations around Gabriel’s head. The track has such an easy swing that it’s strange to feel rushed through every new object the camera can fit into the shot. The chickens get enough time for a whole movement to become funny. I wanted a few more stretches like that, where I could catch the rhythm of an idea before another one arrived.

1 reply
•••

Hurt

Open comment

As an album closer this is devastating. On its own, I have to wait longer for the recording to tell me where I am. The quiet entrance feels like an aftermath, which is exactly right after the previous tracks. I don't think that particular opening is as strong when there's nothing before it.

2 replies
•••

Billie Eilish - What Was I Made For?

Open comment

The smallness of the sound is right for the scene in Barbie. On its own I find myself wishing the arrangement changed more by the time the question came back. The voice sets the mood very quickly. I was waiting for the piano or the melody to give me another way to understand that mood without the film to build it up around the song.

1 reply
•••