What is Reywing?

The One

@one

8 quality commentsMoviesTV Shows
0 Following · 0 Followers

Bir Başkadır – 2. Sezon

Open comment

The series takes a different approach compared with the first season. It doesn’t spend much time deepening the characters. In the first season, we saw all the characters’ stories, and the biggest twists we experienced came from those character stories. Here, though, there’s something different. This time, it felt as if we were watching the characters in a story rather than the characters’ own stories. It was as though Berkun Oya had come up with a story and used the Bir Başkadır universe to convey the message in it. The message was harsh, unsettling. But it wasn’t quite what I had expected. If the chief inspector character had been in the first season, we probably would have understood why he had the imam taken in. Here, we didn’t. Yes, if you think about it a little, you can understand why a character like that would do it, but what I’m trying to say is that this wasn’t the style of Bir Başkadır’s first season. So, did I dislike it? I still loved it.

Reply
Translated from Turkish.
•••

Titanic

Open comment

When the ship’s orchestra breaks up, one of the violinists keeps playing. The others return one by one. Cameron doesn’t present their return as some great act of heroism. The men simply come back together and carry on with what they were doing. As the other instruments join the hymn that began with the violin, the editing takes us off the deck and into rooms inside the ship. The same music accompanies a mother telling her children a bedtime story and an elderly couple embracing as water pours into their cabin. Elsewhere in the film, we understand the ship’s scale through its staircases, crowds, and wide shots of the decks. Here, Cameron brings the scale of the disaster down to beds and faces. The woman putting her children to bed keeps her voice as ordinary as if it were just another night. The elderly couple’s scene is brief enough to read at a glance. In both rooms, there is still one small thing people can do for each other. Jack and Rose’s story has carried the audience to the finale, and it moves me that the screenplay makes room for others right then, too. The orchestra knows it can’t save the ship. In those rooms, the film shows me the value of playing for a few more minutes.

Reply
Translated from Turkish.
•••

Hababam Sınıfı

Open comment

At the school revue, just as “Çilli Bom” is cut short, the principal enters the hall with Ferit’s daughter in his arms, and the stage, set up for entertainment moments earlier, suddenly becomes an interrogation room. What’s more, no one has to change places. The students are onstage, the parents in the hall. Eğilmez’s choice of staging makes the principal’s actions all the more visible. The setup is already there for him to embarrass Ferit by asking, in front of everyone, whose child she is. There is none of the mocking ease that has served Ferit throughout the film in Tarık Akan’s delivery of “The child is mine.” Münir Özkul, meanwhile, pauses for a moment before answering the principal’s question. A teacher who could pride himself on knowing what the students were doing in every scene now has to account for why he didn’t tell the administration what he knew. Umur Bugay’s screenplay ties the disciplinary issue that served the comedy at the beginning of the film to a genuinely difficult decision here. The first thing on the principal’s mind is what he will tell the inspector. What stays with me, though, is the child everyone in the hall is forced to look at when the music stops.

Reply
Translated from Turkish.
•••

Züğürt Ağa

Open comment

At the end, we’re glad the tray in Ağa’s hands is empty. For a man who owned a village at the beginning of the film, coming home in the evening with nothing left to sell is actually a tiny triumph. Nesli Çölgeçen does nothing to magnify that triumph. Şener Şen walks away, swinging the tray. In place of the black boots are plastic slippers. Atilla Özdemiroğlu’s music, too, has a slight playfulness that suits that walk. I smile when I see the satisfaction on Şener Şen’s face, then remember all that man has lost just to be able to take pleasure in something so small. I think the real preparation for that walk is his conversation with Kiraz. When Ağa doesn’t know what to do, Kiraz suggests selling çiğ köfte. Having her make that decision in Yavuz Turgul’s screenplay changes a lot. The young woman whose choices others made for her in the village now sees, before Ağa does, how the two of them might get by. Nilgün Nazlı voices the idea with such everyday naturalness that the scene’s weight only registers afterward. It’s clear what has ended when the boots are sold. In Kiraz’s words, we hear what might begin.

Reply
Translated from Turkish.
•••

Inception

Open comment

We know the team is trying to plant an idea in Fischer’s mind right up until the moment of relief when we learn what he’ll find in the safe. Still, we want to believe that his father finally understood him. I think that’s the film’s best trick. Even after Cobb has explained the plan to us, we want it to work. When we move from the snow-covered fortress into the room tiled with glossy black tiles, the scale of the film changes in an instant. Outside, people are trying to take over a fortress. Inside, Cillian Murphy waits for a few words to come from his father’s lips. Pete Postlethwaite delivers them as though he’s almost out of breath. The change in Murphy’s face doesn’t come right away, either. Fischer is trying to understand anew something he’s thought he knew for years. When he sees the paper windmill he made as a child beside the will in the safe, we understand why that little object we saw earlier in a photograph is there. For Fischer, the fact that his father kept it is more convincing than anything he could say. And then there’s Hans Zimmer’s music. The strings swell as the safe is about to open. At that moment, the editing cuts back to the van falling and the elevator. A farewell scene that could breathe on its own in another film is placed here within the team’s race against time. We’re glad Fischer finally hears what he wants to hear, while also waiting for the heist to succeed. Because Nolan makes us feel both things at once, I’m a little embarrassed by the relief I feel when the scene ends. That, too, makes me feel the power of cinema. When Fischer wakes up, he believes for the first time in his life that he can step off the path his father laid out for him. That belief may genuinely do him good. And yet he owes that sense of freedom to the people who made the decision on his behalf. This is the question that stays with me after the film ends: If you give someone the courage to choose their own life, but have already chosen the path they’ll take, how much freedom have you really given them?

Reply
Translated from Turkish.
•••

Eşkıya

Open comment

The film is, in fact, about an entire Eastern culture, told through the figure of the eşkıya—a brigand produced by that culture. The eşkıya’s path leads to Istanbul, and the film’s most powerful conflict begins almost automatically. The relationship he forms with the first Istanbul resident he meets on the way sets the film’s central conflict in motion at its most compelling point. When an Eastern man (the eşkıya) and a young Western man (Cumali) have to build a relationship of trust, simply observing how each behaves offers valuable insight into the profound differences between cultures. Of course, there are many details in the rest of the film, but it is hard for a film that starts from such a powerful conflict and such a strong opening point to be bad. And with master actors like Şener Şen and Uğur Yücel, and a master screenwriter and director like Yavuz Turgul, it is inevitable that this story should be a masterpiece.

Reply
Translated from Turkish.
•••

G.O.R.A.

Open comment

It is an important film because it was a first for Turkish cinema. Yeşilçam cinema had also produced science-fiction films, but it had never made a serious comedy film like this, combining such absurd comedy with relatively decent effects. It is also significant that the film came out when audiences most loved and embraced Cem Yılmaz’s energy and sense of humor. At the time, Cem Yılmaz and the kind of humor he represented were “new.” The effects, cinematography, and direction were top-notch for the standards of the time. Even viewed today, the film’s quality does not look too dated. This also contributes to its cult status. What’s more, the film’s lines became catchphrases for years. The film itself alluded to many other films, while many films made afterward have alluded to G.O.R.A. as well. These details show just how great its impact was.

Reply
Translated from Turkish.
•••

Bir Zamanlar Anadolu'da

Open comment

This is the pinnacle of NBC’s cinema. In this film, you can see NBC’s passion for photography and composition, profound psychological observations, and striking sociological insights all come together. The best part is that it conveys all of this to the audience without being didactic—often without a word, relying solely on the power of cinema. That, after all, is exactly what makes NBC’s cinema so valuable. I think it deserves a place among the 100 greatest films of all time, anywhere in the world. Because you don’t have to be born in Turkey to be moved by this film. You just have to be human.

Reply
Translated from Turkish.
•••