What is Reywing?

Sufjan Stevens - Fourth of July

Songs
RSS 8.8
4 quality comments
Open comment

I prefer the little questions in the verses to the repeated thought at the end. The questions let me hear two people trying to take care of each other. Once the ending turns into a sentence that applies to everyone, I miss that uncertainty. I'd have let the piano carry a few of the last repeats by itself.

2 replies
•••
Open comment

Sufjan doesn't need a different voice to make me hear both sides of the conversation. One set of lines wants to understand what happened. Another wants to know whether the person asking is all right. Keeping the delivery so close across that switch makes it feel like something he's still hearing in his own head.

Reply
•••
Open comment

The piano is steady enough that a tiny hesitation in the voice feels like a long time. I like that it never tries to tell me when the saddest part is. It gives each question the same patient place to land.

Reply
•••
Open comment

I want the last line to stay as long as it does. The first time through I hear the bluntness. A few passes later, the way he says it seems more important than the words. It's a good use of repetition because it gives me time to stop waiting for a more comforting answer.

Reply
•••